Independent · Nonprofit · Open access
Deep Lex

Individual case record

Feldt v. Apple Inc.

Economic Harm & Market ManipulationStatus: Active

Cause: 28:1332 Diversity-Product Liability

View on CourtListener ↗
Court
D. Utah
Docket
2:25-cv-00353
Filed
5 May 2025
AI system
Apple Intelligence

Individual case record

Overview

The Plaintiff, Skyler Mamone Feldt, brings a putative class action against Apple Inc. alleging that Apple engaged in false and deceptive advertising by marketing AI-powered features for the iPhone 16 lineup that did not exist and could not be delivered on the promised timeline. The Complaint alleges that beginning in June 2024, Apple promoted "Apple Intelligence" and an AI-enhanced Siri with "superpowers" to drive sales of the iPhone 16, despite knowing internally that the features were not functional. The Plaintiff seeks statutory damages, declaratory relief and attorneys' fees under the Utah Consumer Sales Practices Act.

Facts & Claims

Apple announced "Apple Intelligence" at its Worldwide Developers Conference on 10 June 2024, promising a suite of AI features including a transformed Siri with "onscreen awareness," "personal context" capabilities, and the ability to take "hundreds of new actions" across applications. Apple's marketing showed Siri answering questions such as "When is mum's flight landing?" by searching across a user's texts, emails and real-time data. In September 2024, Apple launched a television advertising campaign featuring these capabilities ahead of the iPhone 16's pre-sale.

The Complaint alleges that Apple knew these claims were false at the time they were made. Internal reports indicate that Apple executives, including software engineer Craig Federighi, "voiced strong concerns internally that the features didn't work properly - or as advertised - in their personal testing" and that Apple's AI division believes the features may need to be rebuilt "from scratch." On 1 May 2025, Apple CEO Tim Cook publicly acknowledged that Apple "need[s] more time to complete our work" on the AI features. The Better Business Bureau's National Advertising Division issued a recommendation on 22 April 2025 that Apple discontinue or modify its availability claims, finding that Apple's "Available Now" representations were misleading and unsupported.

The Plaintiff purchased an iPhone 16 Pro Max in October 2024 in Murray, Utah, having watched Apple's advertising and relied on representations about the device's AI capabilities. He alleges he paid more than he otherwise would have because of Apple's false claims.

The sole asserted cause of action is violation of the Utah Consumer Sales Practices Act, Utah Code § 13-11-1 et seq., for misrepresenting that the iPhone 16 had characteristics, uses and benefits it did not have, and for engaging in unconscionable acts through false promises of AI-enhanced features.

The proposed class comprises all persons in Utah who purchased an iPhone 16, iPhone 16e, iPhone 16 Plus, iPhone 16 Pro or iPhone 16 Pro Max on or after 10 June 2024 for personal, family or household purposes. The Plaintiff seeks $2,000 in statutory damages per class member, a declaratory judgment, attorneys' fees and total damages exceeding $5,000,000. The case was transferred by stipulation to the Northern District of California, San Jose Division on 20 May 2025.

This summary is provided for educational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Allegations described are those made in the filings. Please consult the underlying source documents.

Source documents

Documents

Read the complaint and available amendments. For the latest filings, view the source docket ↗.

Loading document records…

Connections

Related content

Models & Systems

Procedural record

Court & docket history

Docket entries from the past three months. For the complete history and latest filings, follow the source docket.

View full docket on CourtListener ↗

Loading docket entries…

Latest filing recorded: 21 May 2025.